Where to Buy Old Coins Online

The world of numismatics (old coin collecting) is both fascinating and rewarding. Whether you're after classic heritage pieces, rare error coins, or investment-grade collectibles, knowing where to buy old coins online matters. In this guide, we’ll walk you through top platforms, tips for staying safe, and search-friendly keywords to boost your blog’s SEO.

 

Why Buying Online is Great for Coin Collectors

• Unparalleled variety – access coins from across eras and continents.
• Competitive pricing – compare listings and landed costs easily.
• Expert grading and authentication – many sellers offer PCGS or NGC-certified coins.
• Secure and reputable platforms – especially important for high-value pieces.

Top Places to Buy Old Coins Online

1. 1. SCOINS (scoins.in)

A trusted Indian platform offering rare coins, banknotes, stamps, and collectibles. The site appeals to both seasoned numismatists and beginners with organized categories like “Coins,” “Banknotes,” “Under 99,” and even accessories and blogs SCOINS INDIA.

 

1. 2. Established US & Global Dealers

APMEX – A respected marketplace with a vast catalog of rare and vintage coins—including ancient and modern collectibles 

Littleton Coin Company – Online seller since 1945 with a strong reputation, expert grading, fast shipping, and a 45-day satisfaction guarantee

Heritage Auctions & Great Collections – Premium auction houses ideal for rare, high-end pieces, offering expert vetting and robust auction platforms 

 

1. 3. Coins Online

A specialist in precious metals and collectible coins. Known for transparent pricing, secure payment options, and a 35+ year track record 

 

1. 4. Catawiki

An online auction-driven platform for collectibles, including rare coins. Offers weekly auctions, global reach, and the excitement of bidding 

 

1. 5. eBay (with Caution)

A ubiquitous marketplace where you can find almost anything—from budget wheat pennies to five-figure rarities. Best suited for lower-priced items; buyers must do rigorous due diligence on seller ratings and authenticity 

 

1. 6. Grading Agencies: PCGS & NGC

Look for coins graded by PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) to ensure authenticity and condition transparency 

Safety Tips for Buying Coins Online

1. Stick to reputable dealers or auction houses.
2. Prefer graded coins for authenticity and condition clarity.
3. Compare “sold” prices on eBay or platforms like Coin Hunter or Change Checker before buying 
4. Beware of overhyped listings—e.g., some coins falsely labeled "rare" (like a 2020 Donation Dollar) are actually abundant 
5. Know what makes coins valuable: low mintage, special designs, minting errors. Rare coins like the Kew Gardens 50p or error coins can sell for hundreds or thousands
6. Use in-person or insured shipping for high-value items.